Your prospecting campaigns are built to find NEW customers — but they're also reaching people who bought from Lulu in the last 90 days. You already have a '90-day purchasers' audience built; you just haven't added it to the exclusion list on those campaigns.
The dollar waste is modest (~$480/mo), but the bigger cost is brand experience. Someone who ordered a case last month is now seeing 'try Lulu for the first time' ads. The fix is 30 seconds per ad set.